Year

Date

Opponent

Us

Them

Result

W

L

T

OT

Where

Location

Field

Coach

Notes

1905

9/30

Toronto

5

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Central Park

Will Knox

1909

10/30

Toronto

12

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Central Park

Mike Duty

1911

9/30

Toronto

10

0

W

1

Away

Toronto

1911

11/11

Toronto

11

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Central Park

1921

10/29

Toronto

27

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Central Park

R. O. Detrick

1924

11/15

Toronto

0

26

L

1

Away

Toronto

Kilgus Field

Carl Zimmerman

1928

11/17

Toronto

19

12

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Dave Evans

1929

11/16

Toronto

6

13

L

1

Away

Toronto

Dave Evans

1930

10/25

Toronto

6

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Dave Evans

1931

10/23

Toronto

28

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Frank Abbey

first night game at Wellsville

1932

10/22

Toronto

32

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Frank Abbey

1933

10/20

Toronto

21

0

W

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Dave Evans

1934

10/20

Toronto

12

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Dave Evans

1935

10/18

Toronto

28

13

W

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Bill Storer

1936

10/16

Toronto

6

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Bill Storer

1937

10/15

Toronto

7

19

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Bill Storer

1938

10/14

Toronto

7

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Bill Storer

1939

10/13

Toronto

0

6

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Bill Storer

1940

10/11

Toronto

18

0

W

1

Away

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Bill Storer

1941

10/10

Toronto

13

12

W

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

John Jasper

1942

10/9

Toronto

14

6

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Monk Montgomery

1943

10/8

Toronto

6

14

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

John Cabas

1944

10/6

Toronto

0

6

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Wally Ingalls

1945

10/5

Toronto

13

12

W

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Wally Ingalls

1946

10/4

Toronto

0

33

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Mearle Atkins

1947

10/2

Toronto

0

39

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Ralph Lutz

1948

10/1

Toronto

0

22

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Mike Rodak

1949

10/7

Toronto

0

33

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Mike Rodak

1950

10/6

Toronto

22

7

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Chuck Sell

1951

10/5

Toronto

6

7

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Chuck Sell

1952

10/3

Toronto

0

18

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Chuck Sell

1953

10/9

Toronto

6

19

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Al Checkler

1954

9/24

Toronto

13

6

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Al Checkler

1955

9/23

Toronto

7

19

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Al Checkler

1956

9/21

Toronto

19

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Al Checkler

1957

9/20

Toronto

7

20

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

William Radd

1958

9/19

Toronto

12

26

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Ken Woods

1959

9/25

Toronto

0

28

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Ken Woods

1960

9/23

Toronto

36

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Ken Woods

1961

9/22

Toronto

14

8

W

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Ken Woods

1962

9/21

Toronto

28

8

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Ken Woods

1963

9/20

Toronto

12

15

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Ken Woods

1964

9/25

Toronto

20

46

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Ken Woods

1965

9/24

Toronto

14

36

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Ken Woods

1966

9/23

Toronto

0

12

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Ken Woods

1968

9/20

Toronto

26

18

W

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Howard Gilger

1969

9/19

Toronto

0

34

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Howard Gilger

1970

9/25

Toronto

20

14

W

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Howard Gilger

1971

9/24

Toronto

29

8

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Howard Gilger

1972

9/22

Toronto

7

14

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Howard Gilger

1973

9/21

Toronto

0

6

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Howard Gilger

1974

10/18

Toronto

6

40

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Howard Gilger

1975

10/17

Toronto

14

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Howard Gilger

1976

10/1

Toronto

6

7

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Howard Gilger

1977

9/30

Toronto

0

6

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Howard Gilger

1978

9/29

Toronto

8

14

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Howard Gilger

1979

9/28

Toronto

20

13

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Howard Gilger

1980

9/26

Toronto

0

7

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Mike McVay

1981

10/2

Toronto

0

26

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Mike McVay

1982

10/1

Toronto

6

28

L

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Mike McVay

1983

9/30

Toronto

0

13

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Mike McVay

1984

9/28

Toronto

28

22

W

1

Away

Toronto

Toronto Stadium

Mike McVay

1986

10/31

Toronto

13

26

L

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Mike McVay

1987

10/30

Toronto

26

12

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Mike McVay

1988

10/28

Toronto

0

21

L

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Mike McVay

1989

9/15

Toronto

10

0

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Mike McVay

1990

9/14

Toronto

22

13

W

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Bob Rudder

1991

9/20

Toronto

18

20

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Bob Rudder

1992

9/25

Toronto

26

22

W

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Robert Thayer

1993

9/24

Toronto

48

29

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Robert Thayer

1994

9/23

Toronto

18

7

W

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Robert Thayer

1995

8/31

Toronto

43

6

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Eric Meek

1996

8/29

Toronto

20

6

W

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Eric Meek

1997

8/28

Toronto

6

8

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Eric Meek

1998

9/3

Toronto

14

21

L

1

1OT

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Eric Meek

1999

8/26

Toronto

16

36

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Eric Meek

2000

8/24

Toronto

0

19

L

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Eric Meek

2001

10/5

Toronto

25

6

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Eric Meek

2002

10/4

Toronto

12

28

L

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Eric Meek

2003

10/3

Toronto

7

33

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Ron Paul

2004

10/8

Toronto

14

19

L

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Ron Paul

2005

9/2

Toronto

18

14

W

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Ron Paul

2006

9/1

Toronto

18

14

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Ron Paul

2007

8/31

Toronto

0

21

L

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Dave Skinner

2008

8/29

Toronto

46

14

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Dave Skinner

2009

9/4

Toronto

15

14

W

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Dave Skinner

2010

8/27

Toronto

13

12

W

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Dave Skinner

2011

8/27

Toronto

16

8

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Dave Skinner

2012

8/25

Toronto

42

13

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Dave Skinner

2013

8/31

Toronto

31

6

W

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Rich Wright

2014

8/29

Toronto

24

7

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Rich Wright

2015

8/27

Toronto

13

22

L

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Derrick Spann

2016

8/26

Toronto

16

36

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Derrick Spann

2017

10/27

Toronto

40

34

W

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Robert Ramsey

2018

10/26

Toronto

0

37

L

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Robert Ramsey

2019

8/30

Toronto

26

15

W

1

Away

Toronto

Clarke Hinkle Field

Robert Ramsey

2022

8/18

Toronto

8

34

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Robert Ramsey

2025

9/5

Toronto

19

49

L

1

Home

Wellsville

Nicholson Stadium

Jim Tsilimos

1,370

1,493

50

48

0

.510

13.98

15.23

-1.26