| Year | Date | Opponent | Us | Them | Result | W | L | T | OT | Where | Location | Field | Coach | Notes | |
| 1930 | 10/4 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 6 | 13 | L | 1 | Home | Cincinnati | Elder Stadium | Walter Bartlett | |||||
| 1946 | 9/21 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 26 | 6 | W | 1 | Away | Indianapolis | Walter Bartlett | ||||||
| 2002 | 10/18 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 45 | 30 | W | 1 | Home | Cincinnati | Elder Stadium | Doug Ramsey | |||||
| 2003 | 10/17 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 21 | 7 | W | 1 | Away | Indianapolis | Doug Ramsey | ||||||
| 2018 | 8/31 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 39 | 34 | W | 1 | Away | Indianapolis | Doug Ramsey | ||||||
| 2019 | 9/6 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 38 | 31 | W | 1 | 1OT | Home | Cincinnati | Elder Stadium | Doug Ramsey | ||||
| 2020 | 10/2 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 14 | 36 | L | 1 | Away | Indianapolis | Doug Ramsey | ||||||
| 189 | 157 | 5 | 2 | 0 | .714 | ||||||||||
| 27.00 | 22.43 | 4.57 |