Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Place Location Field Coach Notes
1985 11/9 Philo 20 12 W 1       Home Thornville   Paul Culver playoff at Thornville
1985 11/16 Ironton 20 33 L   1     Neutral Portsmouth Spartan Municipal Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Portsmouth
1986 11/7 Orrville 0 35 L   1     Neutral Zanesville John D. Sulsberger Memorial Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Zanesville
1987 11/13 Dover 25 24 W 1       Neutral Zanesville John D. Sulsberger Memorial Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Zanesville
1987 11/20 Ironton 27 14 W 1       Neutral Portsmouth Spartan Municipal Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Portsmouth
1987 11/27 Dayton Forest Park 21 7 W 1       Away Dayton Welcome Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Dayton
1987 12/5 Cardinal Mooney 7 30 L   1     Neutral Columbus Ohio Stadium Paul Culver championship at Columbus
1992 11/13 Claymont 21 14 W 1       Neutral Newark White Field Paul Culver playoff at Newark
1992 11/20 Ironton 12 49 L   1     Neutral Portsmouth Spartan Municipal Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Portsmouth
1993 11/13 Vinton County 35 42 L   1     Neutral Groveport   Paul Culver playoff at Groveport
1994 11/11 Steubenville 14 35 L   1     Neutral St. Clairsville Red Devil Stadium Paul Culver playoff at St. Clairsville
1996 11/9 Indian Creek 28 6 W 1       Neutral St. Clairsville Red Devil Stadium Paul Culver playoff at St. Clairsville
1996 11/16 Canfield 19 13 W 1       Neutral Dover Crater Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Dover
1996 11/23 Columbus DeSales 7 26 L   1     Neutral Lancaster Fulton Field Paul Culver playoff at Lancaster
1998 11/14 West Branch 16 22 L   1     Neutral New Philadelphia Quaker Stadium Paul Culver playoff at New Philadelphia
1999 11/5 Louisville 14 7 W 1       Away Louisville   Paul Culver playoff at Louisville
1999 11/12 Poland Seminary 6 17 L   1     Away New Philadelphia Quaker Stadium Paul Culver playoff at New Philadelphia
2001 11/2 Northwest Canal Fulton 21 22 L   1     Away Canal Fulton Dr. Martin Smilek Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Canal Fulton
2002 11/2 Licking Valley 0 28 L   1     Away Newark Randy Baughman Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Newark
2003 10/31 Dover 27 8 W 1       Away Dover Crater Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Dover
2003 11/7 Northwest Canal Fulton 26 28 L   1     Neutral Newcomerstown Lee Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Newcomerstown
2004 11/6 Cambridge 34 7 W 1       Home Thornville Paul Culver Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Thornville
2004 11/13 Steubenville 22 18 W 1       Neutral Dover Crater Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Dover
2004 11/20 Northwest Canal Fulton 0 14 L   1     Neutral Mansfield Arlin Field Paul Culver playoff at Mansfield
2005 11/4 Gallia Academy 42 35 W 1     1OT Away Gallipolis Memorial Field Paul Culver playoff at Gallipolis
2005 11/11 Indian Hill 31 26 W 1       Neutral Springfield Panther Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Springfield
2005 11/18 Columbus DeSales 0 28 L   1     Neutral Newark White Field Paul Culver playoff at Newark
2008 11/1 Franklin 33 7 W 1       Home Thornville Paul Culver, Jr. Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Thornville
2008 11/8 Eastmoor Academy 6 28 L   1     Neutral Columbus DeSales Alumni Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Columbus
2010 11/6 Salem 41 13 W 1       Home Thornville Paul Culver, Jr. Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Thornville
2010 11/13 Dover 28 34 L   1   1OT Neutral Zanesville John D. Sulsberger Memorial Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Zanesville
2011 11/4 Dover 53 68 L   1     Away Dover Crater Stadium Paul Culver playoff at Dover
2016 11/5 Columbus DeSales 13 55 L   1     Away Columbus DeSales Alumni Stadium Paul Culver III playoff at Columbus
2018 11/2 Bellbrook 27 19 W 1       Away Bellbrook   Paul Culver III playoff at Bellbrook
2018 11/9 Granville 20 7 W 1       Neutral Newark White Field Paul Culver III playoff at Newark
2018 11/16 Eastmoor Academy 14 20 L   1     Neutral Lancaster Fulton Field Paul Culver III playoff at Lancaster
2019 11/8 Jonathan Alder 13 35 L   1     Away Plain City Volunteer Field Paul Culver III playoff at Plain City
2020 10/16 Columbus South 27 0 W 1       Home Thornville Paul Culver, Jr. Stadium Paul Culver III playoff at Thornville
2020 10/23 Columbus Bishop Watterson 28 20 W 1       Home Thornville Paul Culver, Jr. Stadium Paul Culver III playoff at Thornville
2020 10/30 Columbus Bishop Hartley 6 10 L   1     Away Columbus Jack Ryan Field Paul Culver III playoff at Columbus
2021 10/29 Columbus DeSales 14 21 L   1     Away Columbus DeSales Alumni Stadium Paul Culver III playoff at Columbus
2022 10/28 Circleville 26 0 W 1       Home Thornville Paul Culver, Jr. Stadium Paul Culver III playoff at Thornville
2022 11/4 Washington Court House 60 34 W 1       Home Thornville Paul Culver, Jr. Stadium Paul Culver III playoff at Thornville
2022 11/11 Bloom-Carroll 7 17 L   1     Neutral Lancaster Fulton Field Paul Culver III playoff at Lancaster
2023 10/27 Morgan 49 28 W 1       Home Thornville Paul Culver, Jr. Stadium Paul Culver III playoff at Thornville
2023 11/3 Gallia Academy 42 0 W 1       Home Thornville Paul Culver, Jr. Stadium Paul Culver III playoff at Thornville
2023 11/10 Columbus Bishop Hartley 34 27 W 1       Neutral Newark White Field Paul Culver III playoff at Newark
2023 11/17 Steubenville 7 14 L   1     Neutral New Philadelphia Woody Hayes Quaker Stadium Paul Culver III playoff at New Philadelphia
2025 10/31 Granville 28 30 L   1     Away Granville Walter J. Hodges Stadium Paul Culver III playoff at Granville
                             
      1,071 1,087   24 25 0 .490          
      21.86 22.18 -0.33