Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes  
1970 9/11 St. Marys, WV 12 47 L   1     Away St. Marys Imlay Field Ron Jennings    
1971 9/10 St. Marys, WV 0 70 L   1     Away St. Marys Imlay Field Ron Jennings    
1972 9/9 St. Marys, WV 6 15 L   1     Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Homer Weekley    
1973 9/7 St. Marys, WV 0 16 L   1     Away St. Marys Imlay Field Homer Weekley    
1974 9/7 St. Marys, WV 6 21 L   1     Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Homer Weekley    
1975 9/5 St. Marys, WV 57 10 W 1       Away St. Marys Imlay Field Homer Weekley    
1976 9/25 St. Marys, WV 0 21 L   1     Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Homer Weekley    
1977 9/23 St. Marys, WV 6 27 L   1     Away St. Marys Imlay Field Homer Weekley    
1978 9/22 St. Marys, WV 0 0 T     1   Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Dave Bonnette    
1979 9/21 St. Marys, WV 15 27 L   1     Away St. Marys Imlay Field Dave Bonnette    
1980 9/19 St. Marys, WV 20 50 L   1     Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Bob Daquilante    
1981 9/11 St. Marys, WV 8 25 L   1     Away St. Marys Imlay Field Bob Daquilante    
1982 9/17 St. Marys, WV 14 35 L   1     Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Jim Stalnaker    
1983 9/16 St. Marys, WV 3 39 L   1     Away St. Marys Imlay Field Jim Forgrave    
1984 9/14 St. Marys, WV 0 31 L   1     Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Bic Tice    
1992 9/4 St. Marys, WV 17 14 W 1       Away St. Marys Imlay Field Vince Elder    
1993 9/3 St. Marys, WV 18 0 W 1       Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Vince Elder    
1994 9/2 St. Marys, WV 6 20 L   1     Away St. Marys Imlay Field Russ Morris    
1995 9/1 St. Marys, WV 38 12 W 1       Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Russ Morris    
1996 9/6 St. Marys, WV 8 7 W 1       Away St. Marys Imlay Field Russ Morris    
1997 9/5 St. Marys, WV 24 15 W 1       Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Russ Morris    
1998 9/11 St. Marys, WV 14 25 L   1     Away St. Marys Imlay Field Russ Morris    
1999 10/15 St. Marys, WV 38 0 W 1       Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Russ Morris    
2000 10/13 St. Marys, WV 13 0 W 1       Away St. Marys Imlay Field Russ Morris    
2001 10/12 St. Marys, WV 27 0 W 1       Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Russ Morris    
2002 10/25 St. Marys, WV 20 14 W 1       Away St. Marys Imlay Field Russ Morris    
2003 10/24 St. Marys, WV 48 0 W 1       Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Russ Morris    
2006 10/13 St. Marys, WV 6 57 L   1     Away St. Marys Imlay Field Todd Bradford    
2007 10/12 St. Marys, WV 18 60 L   1     Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Todd Bradford    
2008 10/10 St. Marys, WV 34 54 L   1     Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Todd Bradford    
2009 10/16 St. Marys, WV 32 0 W 1       Away St. Marys Imlay Field Todd Bradford    
2020 10/30 St. Marys, WV 20 55 L   1     Away St. Marys Bill Hanlin Stadium Russ Morris    
2025 9/26 St. Marys, WV 14 37 L   1     Home New Matamoras Cougar Field Damon Metheney    
2026 9/25 St. Marys, WV               Away St. Marys Bill Hanlin Stadium Damon Metheney    
                               
      542 804   12 20 1 .379            
      16.42 24.36 -7.94